|
My first experience with a Steinberger R-Trem was with as Steinberger Spirit GU-7R from the now defunct MusicYo.com. It is a beautiful guitar but from the first time I played it, there was something wrong with the highly touted R-Trem.  The first problem that I had with the R-Trem was the screw used to tension the main spring. The screw was really hard to turn and felt really rough. It turns out that the threads for the screw were stripped. Tough news for someone who had been looking forward to owning a Steinberger for so long. After getting over the disappointment, the busted threads were drilled out and a keps style lock nut was added to replace the threads. The screw used to tension the main trem spring is now nice and smooth.
After fixing the main spring screw, there was more trouble. Whenever the R-Trem was moved, it made a creaking sound! What next! After having a close look, I discovered that the front of the bridge was rubbing up against the body. Was the trem not installed properly in the cavity? Was the whole thing somehow defective? I didn't know and wanted to play the guitar right away I solved what was in front of me. I took a metal file to the bridge and filed off enough metal so that the bridge didn't rub on the body anymore. Goodbye squeaky noise!
By now, the guitar was playing really beautifully. Unfortunately, with a lot of playing, the bridge started to squeek and creak again. The bridge was being pulled into the body. What the heck! I wasn't going to keep filing the bridge away! After searching on the internet and taking the R-Trem apart again, it looked like the dreaded and infamous bending post problem had reared its ugly head. How could the posts bend? Well, the posts weren't bending, the cheap metal that the posts were screwed into was bending! Aaargh! That was it! I cut off the part of the metal holding the posts and replace that wimpy stuff with some proper chunks of steel.  Soft metal (zinc) replaced with proper steel pieces Finally, all problems solved! Right? Nope, the soft metal (probably zinc) that most of the R-Trem is made out of is causing another problem. It's not affecting how the trem works too much yet but the tab or bracket that transfers the force of the main trem spring to balance out string tension is starting to bend.  Spring tab/bracket starting to lean/bend backwards I think that a lot of these problems make a strong case that the material used to make the R-Trem just isn't up to the task of keeping everything in working order in the long term. Either that or the R-Trem just wasn't designed to last.
One of the cool thinks about the R-Trem is the locking mechanism that allows you to play with a floating or fixed bridge. It also allows you to lock the bridge in tune if one of the strings break. Of course, this would be a really cool feature if it actually worked properly! On the R-Trem, there is just too much slop in the pin that holds the locking arm in place and between the locking jaw and locking stud. The lock really doesn't perform as promised since you can still wiggle the bridge when it's locked. If I can wiggle the bridge, then the strings can easily go out of tune or not be the same tuning when floating as it is when locked. A locking bridge is a good idea but the design on the R-Trem just doesn't deliver. The GU-7R with R-Trem plays really well and is a beautiful sounding instrument when it is working well. Unfortunately, some of the design is lacking and the whole thing seems to always be tending towards self destruction!
54 Comments
VentureShadow
15/9/2018 03:21:39 pm
The R-trem on my costly Steinberger GR4 had similar problems including not staying in tune and requiring far too much force to use. I replaced it with a new Steinberger R-trem but it worked well only a few months. I recently replaced it with an equivalent of the S-trem bought directly from China through Ebay. I had to rout out the cavity to fit and add a shim block I made, all using a moto-tool. This was successful. The new S-trem stays in tune, works smoothly and is easy to use. It uses single ball strings not double ball. Here is a link to it: https://www.ebay.com/itm/Set-of-6-String-Tremolo-Bridge-Tailpiece-for-Headless-Electric-Guitar-Parts/302554764401?epid=15010883729&hash=item4671ab5471:g:slsAAOSwXsFaisjZ
Mitch
15/9/2018 03:43:40 pm
Thanks for the comment. Sorry about the formatting. I'm fixing that as we speak! Cheers!
Mitch
15/9/2018 04:43:09 pm
Very nice! Thanks for the comment, the link and for pointing out that the fonts on my blog comments were messed up!
Tetzip
28/2/2019 05:22:10 am
Hi VentureShadow, 25/8/2020 02:49:43 pm
Hi, Tetzip, I just noticed your reply. That Chinese S-trem equivalent continues to work properly. I have lubricated it once or twice, but I had to do that with a bonafide Steinberger trans-trem on a different guitar. The trans-trem took far more time and effort. Anyway the Chinese S-trem stays in tune and is a pleasure to use, with only a light touch needed to employ vibrato. There's a video of my playing my composition "Waterfall" on YouTube using this vibrato on the Steinberger USA GR4 guitar, on the VentureShadow channel.
Scott
29/5/2019 04:07:15 am
I disagree that the design is bad. I think, with the proper material (read:steel) and paying attention to tolerances (with the locking part of the bridge), that it would be a good piece of gear. Unfortunately, the desire for profit over-road the need for a good track record and reputation.
Mitch
29/5/2019 08:15:35 am
Hi Scott. Thanks for your comments. Yes, I am working on a complete replacement bridge. Getting very close to the final prototype using a design and materials that offer excellent performance and durability at a reasonable price. The interesting thing about the R-Trem is that it was designed to be made by die casting. The exact same shapes made out of stronger materials like steel cannot be die cast and can only be made using processes that make the bridge way too expensive. I've been scratching my head for years on how to make an enhanced replacement bridge out of steel that is affordable and profitable enough to provide good long term support for everyone. I'm working towards having that solution by the end of this year if time after family and work allows. LOL!
Scott
7/6/2019 03:31:32 am
Then I stand corrected. I know nothing of how these things are designed (as far as die casting molds and materials) so if you say so then that is probably it. I wish you luck on getting this thing out. There should be a good market out there for this - assuming the price point is in the "sweet spot". Let me know when they are done and I, assuming I still own a Steinberger, will likely buy one from you.
Mitch
7/6/2019 02:36:11 pm
Hi Scott. Thanks for your interest and support! Cheers, Mitch
mark
15/6/2019 04:21:08 am
love wut your doin. I would like to stay up to date on your progress
Mitch
15/6/2019 10:45:15 pm
Thanks Mark! The MGR Design website homepage has the latest updates that I put on Facebook and Instagram. I should have more updates coming soon. Cheers!
COLIN BRUCE
7/8/2019 08:29:28 am
Hi,
Mitch
7/8/2019 10:45:36 am
Hi Bruce, Thanks for your interest in MGR Design! The r-trem can be a bit stiff on a deep dive but not being able to tell the difference between locked and unlocked seems a bit extreme and sounds like something is wrong.
COLIN BRUCE
12/8/2019 03:38:33 am
Everything seems fine, it seems to me that the spring is too strong to compress, I let the bridge lift way above the point where it locks and restrung it and tuned it to 440, there is a very slight reduction in tension, is there a 'weaker' spring you can apply to the r-trem?
Mitch
12/8/2019 08:10:13 am
Hi Colin,
Scott
7/8/2019 08:50:32 am
Sorry, no comment or suggestion. Just re-subscribing to this blog
Mitch
7/8/2019 10:22:41 am
Cool, welcome back!
COLIN BRUCE
12/8/2019 09:23:12 am
thanks mitch, i'll soldier on, i never use the bar to deep dive, i only used it for vibrato or bending in/out of a note, i'll go and get my sledge hammer from the shed and see if i can talk the r trem into behaving itself lol.
Mitch
12/8/2019 11:25:30 am
lol! good luck colin. One thing I did notice on the bridge that I'm developing is that the action is a little easier than the r-trem. Not that noticeable but enough that I can get a warble sound from the bridge by hitting the whammy bar. I wasn't able to do that on my bridge either on early prototypes until I made a few changes for a smoother pivoting motion. Cheers! Mitch
COLIN BRUCE
15/8/2019 04:46:49 am
Hi Mitch,
Mitch
15/8/2019 09:19:08 am
Hi Bruce, no worries, I love this stuff! You can see from the pictures above what lengths I went through to stop the bridge from rubbing on the body. There were actual dents in the wood from the interference. Of course, this problem just gets worse as the pivot posts continue to tilt forward over time. I designed the MGR bridge so that this could never happen in the first place. Cheers!
Frank
11/11/2019 05:33:52 am
Have my Steinberger Spirit ppro deluxe now a month, and I already encounter some of the issues above. First I thew the horrible pickups out, and put Seymour Duncans in. Of course I had to use a dremel to make the middle single coil fit in the cavity. Push pull pot fort the 2 humbuckers. Then I bought a string adapter to put mmy ernie Ball slinky's 009 in. And then the trouble began.. Every thin e- string broke by the ball end. It not really broke, but sort of unraveled out of tune..just unwinding from the ball- end. I broke already 4 strings this way.. First I thought that -by pulling the string backwards with tuning-, the string near the ball end was scraped off because it touched the edge of the bridge. So I filed a small round piece of the bridge away to give the string some space. Then it happened again.
Mitch
11/11/2019 12:27:01 pm
Hi Frank, that sounds really strange. I had a look at my old r-trem and it doesn't look like the wound part of the string has ever interacted with the bridge or the saddles. Maybe someone else could chime in?
Frank
11/11/2019 12:45:15 pm
Thanks alot Mitch! the next string I will solder. Great Idea!
Rabo Karabekian
25/12/2019 09:02:33 am
Try threading the string through the "ball" end hole once or twice.
Mitch
11/11/2019 03:27:52 pm
No problem! I'm not sure how the r-trems from the 80s were but from my research and the interest I am getting for my new bridge, I think that they all had similar issues. I hope that your string issues go away. Ernie Ball is my favorite string brand too. Cheers!
Frank
25/12/2019 10:42:13 am
Got my string issue solved with soldering near the ball-ends. After wo months, I got my Spirit Pro 'De Luxe'(LOL) in a very smooth state, so that it plays as light as my Ibanez JEM. A lot of work, and I post a link when I put this whole story on a tasty video on YouTube. Anothe month or so. Good holidays everyone!
Mitch
25/12/2019 02:23:48 pm
Hi Frank, that's awesome. Looking forward to the video. Happy Holidays!!
Frank
28/12/2019 03:28:24 pm
In the mean time, I stumbled upon Kiesel Guitars. Very exclusive expensive headless guitars. Do they use the same crappy r-trems or do they have something better? https://www.kieselguitars.com/customshop/
Mitch
29/12/2019 12:01:41 pm
Hi Frank, I'm pretty sure that Kiesel uses a Hipshot headless bridge with extension springs at the back and so do Strandberg and other headless guitars. Those bridges should work just fine but they can't practically be used as a replacement for an r-trem. If you're in the market for a new headless guitar, my impression is that Kiesel makes some really nice guitars.
FrankF
15/4/2020 03:17:25 pm
in a few days i finish my video about the Steinberger Spirit pro deLuxe (lol) It will be devastating. I post a link when I'm ready
Mitch
15/4/2020 07:19:50 pm
Cool!
Frank
16/4/2020 09:57:45 am
oops.. I accidently unsubscribed.. Ill be back.. in one or 2 days I post my Steinberger Spirit PRo GT- Deluxe (what a mouthful for such a piece of cr..)
Frank F
17/4/2020 02:32:29 am
Ok, guys, I just published my 'thoughts' on the Steinberger Spirit Pro GT- DeLuxe
Mitch
17/4/2020 07:38:19 am
Great video Frank! Pretty much spot on. LOL! It's funny that you noticed all of the play in the tuners. I was jiggling those around yesterday as well, comparing them to the design of my bridge. Very nice playing as well. Thank you for sharing!
Matt
10/1/2022 09:58:42 am
Can you repost that video?
Frank
18/4/2020 06:31:11 am
It was a pleasure to do, thanks. But isn't it unbelievable that after all these years nothing has changed? They are for decades producing the same shit. They must have read through the years the problems there were with the trem.. I thingk I was Lucky to change the gauge right away, so I stil have a functioning bridge.But I still keep looking out for a site around this world who sells good spare parts.
zk
4/11/2020 05:35:26 am
That's a bit stressful. I just put a fresh JCustom R-trem into a Hohner and hope all those things will never happen (of course did happen to the old R-trem I received the guitar with). Hohner has R-trem kinda snugly built into the body, so there's no room for things getting bent at all. Fingers crossed, trem works fantastic for now - very stable if predictably stiffer than a Floyd.
Chriss
23/1/2021 03:38:57 pm
Having a spirit gt pro deluxe, I'm also concerned about R-Trem durability.
zk
24/1/2021 03:55:24 am
I had no opportunity to compare with an another functioning R-trem. But tuning stability wise JCustom is almost on par with my double locking Schaller - very good. And seems very well put together in general. I have it just three months, use 9-46 strings, recorded a couple of tracks and didn't manage to break it yet (low standards huh). BTW I believe the guy running this blog has completed his improved version with hardened posts and improved arm and lock mechanisms.
Mitch Regnier
25/1/2021 07:12:50 am
Yes, getting the first units out slowly. :)
Matt Kane
26/10/2021 12:49:49 pm
The "breaking" top E string issue (actually unravelling around the ball-end) can be mitigated with a blob of solder as stated above. If you're lazy like me though, a quicker fix without the faff is to *tightly* wrap up the ball-end and windings in a square inch of aluminium foil before inserting the ball-end into the jaws of the bridge This seems to give the extra grip required to prevent the problem recurring.
Mitch Regnier
26/10/2021 06:46:52 pm
That's cool. Thanks Matt!
zk
27/10/2021 12:17:49 am
Even lazier solution is just switching to factory reinforced strings that have those windings stronger (Slinky Titanium & RPS, reinforced GHS, I think Addarios NYXL are also reinforced, probably plenty more). They cost the same as any other strings really.
Mitch
27/10/2021 07:31:25 am
Always an option for sure. I've been using LaBella strings and they have that extra wrap as well.
Travis Hartnett
1/12/2021 05:29:59 pm
I've always wished for a quality fixed bridge replacement for my R-Trem.
Mitch
2/12/2021 11:21:15 am
Hi Travis, the Series 001 bridge locks really well and behaves like a fixed bridge. That being said, I've already designed the Series 002 bridge, which is a fixed bridge. The Series 002 bridge is not in production yet as I am focusing on the floating bridge. You can check out the Series 001 bridge at https://www.mgr-design.com/series-001.html. 4/2/2022 07:05:55 pm
Mitch, can you please send me a link to view your r-trem clone? What is posted does not work. Also include price, shipping, and contact info.
Mitch Regnier
4/2/2022 08:24:17 pm
Hi Scott, everything you need to know is now on this website's home page. https://www.mgr-design.com/ Enjoy!
Kevin
9/6/2022 07:07:24 pm
Hi Mitch, Can you provide the approximate wait time for a MGR Series-001? I’d submitted my name to the list a couple of days ago.
Mitch
8/7/2022 11:22:04 am
Hi Kevin, sorry I'm so late on a lot of this stuff. My email got messed up and I'm only realizing it now. Anyhow, I'm hoping to have more bridges ready to go in September.
Scott B
28/1/2023 09:30:36 pm
Where are these shipped FROM? Where are they made? How close are you to producing the Series 002 bridge? Also, how many Series 001 bridges have you sold?
Mitch Regnier
29/1/2023 01:59:43 pm
Hi Scott, the bridges are shipped from St. Albert, Alberta, Canada. I make some of the parts but most of the components are sourced from around the world then modified and assembled by me and my family here in St. Albert. There are tons of final finishing and assembly steps to make sure the bridges work exactly as designed. We even make the packaging foam here in Alberta to make sure the units get to our customers in perfect shape every time. I'm at the point where I wear white cotton gloves for almost every step to save time wiping off finger prints at the end before shipping.
Mitch Regnier
29/1/2023 02:05:36 pm
FYI, next two products will be guitar related, of course, but not guitar bridges :) Leave a Reply. |
AuthorProfessionally engineered designs of cool stuff (to me anyway! lol!) Archives
December 2018
Categories |
RSS Feed